Law Office of Seth D. Schraier, P.C.

For individuals in New York City and surrounding areas seeking legal representation under the platform category "Lawyers Near Me," the Law Office of Seth D. Schraier, P.C., located at 158 18 Riverside Dr W Ste 2F, New York, NY 10032, USA, presents a study in contrasting client experiences. While one client offers high praise for Mr. Schraier's dedication and effectiveness in a complex matrimonial case, another expresses significant dissatisfaction with his representation in a family trial. This introduction aims to provide an objective overview based on the available testimonials, allowing local users to consider both perspectives when evaluating their legal options.

The Law Office of Seth D. Schraier, P.C. is situated in New York City, offering a potentially convenient location for residents of Manhattan and nearby areas seeking legal counsel. The office at 158 18 Riverside Dr W Ste 2F suggests a professional environment where clients can discuss their legal matters. For those interested in contacting the firm, the phone number is (914) 907-8632, and the mobile number is +1 914-907-8632. These contact details provide direct access to inquire about the firm's services and schedule consultations.

One detailed review recounts a positive experience with Seth Schraier in a contested matrimonial case in Westchester, New York. The case involved complexities such as a long-term marriage (30+ years) and an adversarial opposing party. The client also noted the unique procedural requirements of the Westchester County Court, which mandated extensive mediation before a trial could be scheduled. According to this client, Mr. Schraier proactively filed numerous motions to bring the case before a judge and diligently argued each one, achieving positive outcomes on almost every motion. This demonstrates a strategic and assertive approach to litigation.

The client further praises Mr. Schraier's consideration of their financial limitations, noting that he did not demand additional fees or exert pressure for more payment despite the protracted nature of the case (spanning four years and involving over 20 court appearances). This suggests a level of empathy and ethical consideration in his billing practices. The review emphasizes Mr. Schraier's unwavering commitment, highlighting his attendance at every court appearance despite a heavy caseload. Additionally, he is credited with facilitating all communication throughout and after mediation, filing successful motions, and skillfully conducting cross-examination during the trial.

Ultimately, the decision after trial was in this client's favor, with the court granting everything they had sought. The client describes Seth Schraier as "the most caring, honest, and passionate attorney I’ve ever met," and highly recommends him to anyone seeking an attorney who will fight wholeheartedly for their clients. The review concludes with a personal note of gratitude, referring to him as not only an "amazing lawyer" but also an "even better person." This testimonial paints a picture of a dedicated, effective, and compassionate attorney who prioritizes his clients' best interests.

However, a contrasting review presents a different perspective on Seth Schraier's representation. This client describes him as "nice and very hardworking," but then states that these qualities did not translate into effective legal representation in their family trial. The client, a self-described "naive nervous young adult," initially felt reassured by Mr. Schraier, who explained the proceedings and discussed the client's account of acting in self-defense. Evidence of bodily harm was also reportedly discussed.

Despite these initial discussions, the client alleges that their side of the story was never told during the trial, and none of the discussed evidence was submitted. The client expresses uncertainty as to the reason for this, suggesting possibilities such as incompetence, being overworked, or a lack of care. The review concludes with the sentiment "you get what you pay for," implying dissatisfaction with the value received for the legal services rendered.

Considering these two divergent accounts is crucial for local users seeking legal representation from the Law Office of Seth D. Schraier, P.C. The positive review highlights dedication, strategic thinking, perseverance, and a caring attitude in a complex matrimonial case. It suggests that Mr. Schraier is willing to go the extra mile for his clients and can achieve significant positive outcomes, particularly in contested high-stakes litigation. However, the negative review raises concerns about the quality of representation in a family trial setting, citing a failure to present the client's case and submit discussed evidence.

It is important for potential clients to consider the nature of their legal needs and weigh these contrasting experiences. For those facing complex and potentially lengthy litigation, particularly in matrimonial law, Mr. Schraier's dedication and tenacity, as described by one client, could be valuable assets. His willingness to attend numerous court appearances and fight diligently for his client's interests is noteworthy. However, individuals involved in other types of family law matters, such as the family trial described in the negative review, may want to delve deeper into Mr. Schraier's approach to such cases and seek further assurances regarding the thorough presentation of their case and evidence.

In conclusion, the Law Office of Seth D. Schraier, P.C. in New York, NY, presents a mixed picture based on the available client reviews. While one client experienced exceptional dedication and a successful outcome in a complex matrimonial case, another reported significant dissatisfaction with the representation received in a family trial. Local users considering Mr. Schraier's services should carefully evaluate their specific legal needs and consider both perspectives when making their decision. Contacting the firm directly to discuss your case and ask specific questions about their approach to cases similar to yours would be a prudent step in making an informed choice about your legal representation.