Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC

Lawyers Near MeNew YorkSuffolk CountyMelvilleBroadhollow Road

445 Broadhollow Rd #25, Melville, NY 11747, USA

3.0

This guy left me 100% alone with a pending motion for summary judgment on a case that the police outright admitted to committing perjury on. He showed up 2 hours late to my 50 h hearing and briefed me in the parking lot 15 minutes before my 1st deposition in my life. I gave him pictures of the responsible parties years before their names were mentioned and he lied to me about accident reconstruction. He refused to forward me the file even though I offered to pay him for work performed. Call me a liar Peter, that cop still following my family and you didn’t do anything about it and the only reason this case failed is because you didn’t amend the claim that I filed pro se and you know it. 5 broken ribs, broken back, pneumonia and you failed to depose not only the ambulance staff, but the guy who actually hit me because you were driving? Call me a liar Peter. You’re a terrible lawyer.

Steeb me
  • Overview
  • (631) 367-7000
  • peterbaronlaw.com

Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC Introduce

When facing legal challenges, particularly those involving personal injury, selecting the right attorney is a critical decision. Within the "Lawyers Near Me" category, the Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC, located in Melville, New York, is a legal practice that handles personal injury cases. This introduction aims to provide local users in Taiwan, who may be seeking legal assistance for personal injury matters within the United States, with an objective overview of the Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC, based on the publicly available client reviews, which present a starkly contrasting range of experiences.

The Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC is situated at 445 Broadhollow Rd #25, Melville, NY 11747, USA. This Melville location suggests a professional office setting for client consultations and legal proceedings. The firm can be reached by phone at (631) 367-7000 or via mobile phone at +1 631-367-7000, offering direct contact for individuals seeking legal assistance.

Based on the limited information available, primarily consisting of two contrasting client reviews, the primary service offered by the Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC appears to be:

  • Personal Injury Law: Representing individuals who have suffered injuries due to the negligence or wrongdoing of others, potentially including car accidents and other incidents. This involves navigating insurance claims, negotiating settlements, and potentially litigating cases in court to seek compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering.

The two client reviews present significantly different perspectives on the features and quality of service provided by the Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC. It is crucial to consider both viewpoints to form a balanced understanding:

  • Positive Review: One client describes Peter Baron as a "top notch lawyer" who handled their personal injury case "meticulously and professionally." This client reports receiving a "sizable settlement" against a difficult insurance company, attributing it to Peter's "hard work." They also highlight his compassion and understanding regarding their injuries and commend his efforts in fighting for justice, ultimately recovering funds for lost income, medical expenses, and pain and suffering. This review strongly recommends his services for personal injury cases.
  • Negative Review: Conversely, another client recounts a profoundly negative experience. This individual alleges being left "100% alone" with a pending motion for summary judgment in a case involving alleged police perjury. They report Peter Baron arriving two hours late to a hearing, providing brief consultation in the parking lot before a deposition, and disregarding evidence provided. The client further accuses Peter of lying about accident reconstruction and refusing to forward the case file despite an offer to pay for work done. This review concludes by labeling Peter Baron a "terrible lawyer," attributing the case's failure to his alleged negligence in not amending the initial claim and failing to depose key witnesses.

Given the diametrically opposed nature of these two reviews, it is challenging to objectively ascertain the typical features and environment of the Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC. One review suggests a professional and meticulous approach leading to positive outcomes, while the other paints a picture of neglect, unprofessionalism, and failure to adequately represent the client's interests. Potential clients must acknowledge this significant discrepancy in reported experiences.

Regarding promotional information, there is no explicit promotional content within the provided reviews. The positive testimonial serves as an implicit endorsement, highlighting a successful outcome and client satisfaction in a personal injury case. However, the severe allegations in the negative review stand in stark contrast and should prompt careful consideration from potential clients.

For local users in Taiwan seeking legal assistance for personal injury matters in the Melville, NY area, the information regarding the Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC presents a complex picture. While one client reports a highly positive experience and recommends his services, another details a deeply negative encounter alleging significant professional shortcomings. Due to this extreme divergence in feedback, it is strongly recommended that potential clients conduct thorough independent research and due diligence before considering engaging this law firm. This may include:

  • Seeking additional reviews or testimonials from other sources online, if available, to gain a broader perspective on client experiences.
  • Contacting the firm directly to inquire about their experience in handling cases similar to your own and to discuss their approach to client representation.
  • Requesting references from past clients and contacting them to learn about their experiences firsthand.
  • Consulting with other legal professionals for their opinions or recommendations on personal injury attorneys in the Melville area.
  • Carefully considering the specific details and allegations made in both positive and negative reviews in relation to your own legal needs and expectations.

Choosing legal representation is a critical decision with significant potential impact on the outcome of your case. The conflicting information available for the Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC underscores the importance of comprehensive research and cautious evaluation to ensure you select an attorney who aligns with your needs and can provide effective and professional legal representation.

In conclusion, the Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC in Melville, New York, handles personal injury cases. However, the available client reviews offer drastically different accounts of the firm's services, ranging from "top notch" and resulting in a "sizable settlement" to allegations of neglect, misrepresentation, and significant professional failings. Potential clients within the "Lawyers Near Me" category are strongly advised to approach this information with caution and conduct extensive independent research to reconcile these conflicting perspectives before making a decision regarding legal representation.

Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC Location

Law Offices of Peter D. Baron, PLLC

445 Broadhollow Rd #25, Melville, NY 11747, USA

Get directions

Reviews

This guy left me 100% alone with a pending motion for summary judgment on a case that the police outright admitted to committing perjury on. He showed up 2 hours late to my 50 h hearing and briefed me in the parking lot 15 minutes before my 1st deposition in my life. I gave him pictures of the responsible parties years before their names were mentioned and he lied to me about accident reconstruction. He refused to forward me the file even though I offered to pay him for work performed. Call me a liar Peter, that cop still following my family and you didn’t do anything about it and the only reason this case failed is because you didn’t amend the claim that I filed pro se and you know it. 5 broken ribs, broken back, pneumonia and you failed to depose not only the ambulance staff, but the guy who actually hit me because you were driving? Call me a liar Peter. You’re a terrible lawyer.

Mar 28, 2025 · Steeb me

Peter Baron is a top notch lawyer. My personal injury case was handled meticulously and professionally. Peter’s hard work got me a sizable settlement for my injuries, against a very difficult car insurance company. Peter was always compassionate and understanding regarding my injuries, and fought for my justice to no avail. Thanks to Peter, I have recovered funds for all the time off from work and medical expenses, as well as pain and suffering. I highly recommend the Law offices of Peter Baron should you fall victim to personal injury, he will fight for your rights and get compensation you deserve.

Dec 10, 2019 · jared219

I am very happy that Peter represented me for my personal injury claim. His office was professional and he was very compassionate. I highly recommend Peter and am thankful for all that he did for me.

Apr 07, 2020 · Tamanna Chhabra

Doesn’t fight hard for his clients.nice guy but not a true lawyer

Mar 07, 2023 · JC 5937

He is awesome Lawyer, caring and understanding.

Dec 09, 2020 · a m

Lawyers Near Me

DiCrescio Law P.C.

DiCrescio Law P.C.

462 Sagamore Ave, East Williston, NY 11596, USA

Capetola & Divins, P.C.

Capetola & Divins, P.C.

2 Hillside Ave. Building C, Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

The Law Office of Amy Sklar

The Law Office of Amy Sklar

2 Hillside Ave. Building C, Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

Wiese & Aydiner, PLLC

Wiese & Aydiner, PLLC

141 Willis Ave, Mineola, NY 11501, USA

The R.M.L. Law Firm, PLLC

The R.M.L. Law Firm, PLLC

145 Willis Ave Ste 4, Mineola, NY 11501, USA

Chet Lukaszewski, P.C.

Chet Lukaszewski, P.C.

145 Willis Ave 2nd Floor, Mineola, NY 11501, USA